In a shocking turn of events, the Queen of Pop was completely shut out, receiving no nominations.

Beyoncé’s CMA Snub Sparks Debate: Was It Fair or Fueled by Bias?

Beyoncé’s venture into country music seemed destined for recognition at the 2024 Country Music Awards (CMA), especially with the success of her chart-topping single Texas Hold ‘Em and her country-inspired album Cowboy Carter. Released in February 2024, the album showcased her versatility and drew widespread acclaim from both fans and critics. However, in a surprising turn, Beyoncé didn’t receive a single nomination.

The snub sent shockwaves through the Beyhive, with fans flooding social media to express their outrage. Many accused the CMAs of bias, calling the decision “spiteful” and even “racist.” One fan vented, “At this point, it’s gotta be spiteful. How do you not nominate her for Artist of the Year after sitting on the Country charts for an entire week? Also, Beyoncé isn’t country, but Post Malone is?”

A Polarizing Foray into Country

Texas Hold ‘Em resonated with audiences for its fun vibe and nods to country’s roots, becoming a Billboard Hot 100 hit and marking a historic moment for Beyoncé as a Black woman in country music. Critics, including Rolling Stone, which ranked the track #192 on its list of the “200 Greatest Country Songs of All Time,” praised her authenticity and vocal performance.

Despite this acclaim, backlash was swift. Actor and singer John Schneider, best known for The Dukes of Hazzard, harshly criticized Beyoncé’s foray into the genre. In an interview with One America News Network, he likened her move into country to a territorial act, saying, “They’ve got to make their mark, just like a dog in a dog walk park. You know, every dog has to mark every tree, right?”

Meanwhile, a country radio station in Oklahoma outright refused to play Texas Hold ‘Em, telling one listener, “We do not play Beyoncé on KYKC as we are a country music station.”

Support and Criticism from Industry Icons

The controversy isn’t Beyoncé’s first brush with resistance in country music. Her 2016 CMA performance of Daddy Lessons with The Chicks faced similar backlash. Reflecting on that moment, Natalie Maines of The Chicks said, “For them to disrespect her that way was disgusting.”

Beyoncé herself has spoken about feeling unwelcome in the country music scene, with some fans interpreting Cowboy Carter as her response to past experiences. Music journalist J’na Jefferson echoed this sentiment: “The whole reason that she even did this (Cowboy Carter) is because they kept shutting her down. She tried to apply ‘Daddy Lessons’ to be in the (Grammys’) country music category in 2016, and they shut it down.”

Even country icon Kelly Clarkson weighed in on the snub. In a September interview with NBC10 Boston, Clarkson expressed surprise at Beyoncé’s lack of nominations, saying, “I kind of find it fascinating because I feel like those songs were everywhere.” Reflecting on her own challenges with the genre, Clarkson added, “It just seemed like the door was closed unless I was all-in… I don’t think people like me, or even Beyoncé, are capable of doing that.”

Differing Perspectives from Country Stars

Other country stars shared mixed reactions. Luke Bryan, in an interview with Andy Cohen Live, offered a nuanced take: “Everybody loved that Beyoncé made a country album. Nobody’s mad about it. But where things get a little tricky… if you’re gonna make country albums, come into our world and be country with us a little bit. Beyoncé can do exactly what she wants to. She’s probably the biggest star in music. But come to an award show and high-five us, and have fun and get in the family, too. And I’m not saying she didn’t do that.”

Dolly Parton also addressed the controversy, offering a more neutral perspective. “I don’t think it was a matter of shutting out, like doing that on purpose. I think it was just more of what the country charts and the country artists were doing, that do that all the time, not just a specialty album,” she said while praising Cowboy Carter.

The Role of Race in the Snub

Beyoncé’s father, Mathew Knowles, didn’t hold back when discussing the possible role of race in the snub. Speaking to TMZ, he stated, “There’s more white people in America, and unfortunately they don’t vote based on ability and achievements. It’s still sometimes a white and black thing.” While clarifying that he wasn’t accusing voters of being racist, he added, “In America, there’s no accountability for people not being accepting of other cultures.”

CMA Winners and the Bigger Picture

At the 2024 CMA Awards, the night’s biggest winners included Morgan Wallen, who took home Entertainer of the Year, and Chris Stapleton, who claimed Male Vocalist of the Year and Single of the Year for White Horse. Lainey Wilson won Female Vocalist of the Year, while Cody Johnson’s Leather earned Album of the Year. Country legend George Strait was honored with the Willie Nelson Lifetime Achievement Award.

While Beyoncé’s absence from the nominations has sparked intense debate, her influence on the genre remains undeniable.

As Cowboy Carter collaborator Shaboozey tweeted, “Thank you @Beyonce for opening a door for us, starting a conversation, and giving us one of the most innovative country albums of all time!”